Skip to content
Keep your pet’s essentials organized in style with our Handmade Poly Pet Toy Box, available in 15 beautiful color options to match any space.
Handcrafted on an Old Order Amish homestead in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, each piece is built from premium poly lumber made from recycled materials. Designed for durability and everyday use, this box will not rot, splinter, or crack making it ideal for both indoor and outdoor use.
A decorative bone accent with paw print cutout adds charm while allowing easy access. Whether placed in a mudroom, entryway, or living space, this piece blends function with timeless design.
Why You’ll Love It
Handcrafted by Amish artisans in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania
Available in 15 color options to match your home or outdoor space
Made from durable poly lumber that will not rot, splinter, or fade
Weather-resistant for indoor or outdoor use
Decorative bone accent with paw print cutout for easy access
Smooth hinged lid for convenient opening and closing
Easy to clean – simply wipe with a damp cloth
Built to last for years with minimal maintenance
Choose Your Color
Select from 15 available poly colors, including classic neutrals and bold statement tones.
Each color is solid throughout the material (not painted), ensuring long-lasting beauty without peeling or chipping.
👉 Tip: Use the dropdown menu above to select your preferred color. The product image will update automatically.
Product Details
Material: High-quality poly lumber (recycled plastic)
Construction: Screwed bone detail with precision paw print cutout
Lid: Smooth hinged top
Use: Indoor or outdoor
Dimensions
Height: 22 inches
Width: 14 inches
Depth: 10 inches
Production & Shipping
Each piece is made to order by Amish craftsmen
Estimated production time: Approximately 10 business days
Perfect For
Dog toy storage
Pet blanket organization
Leash and accessory storage
Mudrooms, entryways, porches, or patios
Shipping
Unless otherwise specified, orders generally ship within 3-7 business days. When your order ships you will be notified via email and provided tracking. In the event of back order you will be notified via email. We ship via USPS, Fed-Ex and UPS. Furniture and other custom orders generally ship within 4-8 weeks. Furniture shipments will be arranged with a third party freight delivery company. Furniture shipping rates are for curbside delivery. You will need to be present and will be responsible for having furniture transported indoors from the curb. Should you require indoor delivery please "Contact Us" for assistance. Should you require expedited delivery for any order please "Contact Us" for expedited shipping options
Returns Policy
We take great pride in 100% customer satisfaction. If for any reason, you're not satisfied with your purchase, we've outlined the following guidelines to help make your return a smooth and seamless experience: You may return your unused item in its original condition and packaging within 14 days of receipt. Please request a return by clicking on "Contact Us" and requesting a return authorization number to expedite your return. Unless your item is received damaged, or there was some error on our part, you will be responsible for all return shipping costs. Custom, handmade items and lighting are subject to a 20% restocking fee. Because refunds will not be issued in full for items damaged in return shipping or returns that are never received, we highly recommend that you insure all return shipments and provide Saving Shepherd with the shipment tracking number. All items are shipped to you in the best possible packaging to ensure that you receive your purchase in perfect condition. Upon receipt, please inspect your package closely. If you receive a damaged item, we will assist you in receiving a replacement or refund as quickly as possible - at no cost to you. Should you observe significant damage to the outer packaging, please reject the shipment and have the carrier return it. If there is minor damage to the packaging, please indicate as such when you sign for the shipment. In the unlikely event that you find your product to be damaged upon opening it please notify Saving Shepherd Support by clicking “Contact Us” Please notify Saving Shepherd of any damaged product within 3 days of receipt.
